Pleural Controversy: Close Needle Pleural Biopsy or Thoracoscopy ‐ Which first?
The most efficient and cost‐effective approach to the diagnosis of pleural exudates remains controversial. Important considerations include the respective diagnostic yields of thoracocentesis, closed pleural biopsy and thoracoscopy; the incremental gain in diagnostic yield when sequentially combining these investigations; and the role of various image modalities.
The diagnostic yield of thoracocentesis is in the order of 60% for malignancy and >90% for tuberculosis (depending on the prevalence). A second aspiration may increase the yield for malignancy, but a third is generally superfluous.Many authorities consider thoracoscopy the investigation of choice in exudative pleural effusions where a thoracocentesis was nondiagnostic and particularly when malignancy is suspected. It a...